Nonprofit Fundraising: What It Costs to Raise a Dollar
Grants are among the cheapest dollars to raise, yet most giving comes from individuals. How to weigh each fundraising channel by its cost and its odds.
Granteon ·
A dollar from a new direct mail donor costs $1.25 to $1.50 to bring in. A dollar from a foundation grant costs about 20 cents.
Those are James Greenfield's benchmarks, and they say more about where your fundraising hours should go than any list of event ideas.
Where the Money Comes From
Giving USA estimates that Americans gave $617.20 billion to charity in 2025. Individuals gave $394.2 billion of it, about 64 percent.
Foundations gave $117.15 billion, about 19 percent. Bequests added $62.19 billion and corporations $43.67 billion.
So foundation grants are a real slice of giving, and a minority one. A plan built only on grants ignores four of every five dollars donors give.
Government money sits outside those totals. In an Urban Institute survey, about two thirds of nonprofits received at least one government grant or contract in 2023, and government supplied about a quarter of the average nonprofit's revenue.
What Each Dollar Costs to Raise
Greenfield's reasonable cost guidelines are the figures most fundraising budgets borrow. Per dollar raised, his table puts foundation grants and corporate gifts at $0.20, direct mail renewals at $0.20 to $0.25, and capital campaigns at $0.10 to $0.20.
Benefit events cost about $0.50 per dollar. That figure counts only gross revenue and direct costs, and Greenfield says to add the indirect and overhead support behind an event to find its true net.
New donors are the expensive line. At $1.25 to $1.50 per dollar, a first direct mail gift loses money, and only the renewals pay it back.
Treat the table as a scale, since it dates to 2002 and leans on older direct mail data. Even as a scale, it makes the point: renewals and grants cost cents per dollar, and a new donor costs more than the first gift brings in.
The Renewal Is Where the Money Is
Acquisition pays only if donors come back, and most do not. The Fundraising Effectiveness Project put overall donor retention at 43.3 percent for 2025.
First gifts fare worse. The project found that "only 11.3% of donors acquired in 2025 had given again by the end of Q2" of 2026.
Meanwhile, the dollars concentrate at the top. In the same report, "Major and Supersize donors give 76.4% of all dollars while making up just 2.9% of donors."
For a small shop, that points the hours at keeping and growing the donors you already have. Events come after that.
Where Grants Fit
Grants are cheap to raise per dollar, but they cost money to carry. Federal awards often pay on reimbursement and come with reporting, and our post on what a federal grant costs before the money arrives puts numbers on both.
They also concentrate risk. In early 2025, the Urban Institute found that 21 percent of nonprofits had lost at least some government funding, and 27 percent had government funding delayed, paused, or frozen.
So size grants so that one lost award does not stop payroll.
The 35 Percent Test
Donors and watchdogs check your ratio, too. Standard 9 of the BBB Wise Giving Alliance says a charity should "spend no more than 35% of related contributions on fund raising."
Grants count toward that test. The standard's related contributions include foundation and government grants, so low cost grant dollars help hold the whole ratio down.
How to Split Your Fundraising Hours
Start with the donors you have. Renew them before you buy new ones, and ask your largest givers in person.
Then apply for the grants you are eligible for, sized against the rest of your budget. Granteon finds the open grants that fit your mission and checks each one's deciding requirements before you write a word. Start free, no card needed.
Every channel has a price per dollar. Know yours, and spend your hours where the dollar is cheapest to raise and most likely to come back.
Sources
- Giving USA: charitable giving rose to $617.20 billion in 2025, surpassing the $600 billion mark for the first time, Giving USA
- Reasonable Cost Guidelines for Solicitation Activities, James M. Greenfield, via OneOC (archived)
- Fundraising Effectiveness Project Reports Strongest Revenue Growth in Five Years, Even as Fewer Donors Give, GivingTuesday
- Donations Are Up, but Donors Are Down, Reports the Fundraising Effectiveness Project, GivingTuesday
- Government Grants and Contracts for Nonprofits in 2023, Urban Institute
- How Government Funding Disruptions Affected Nonprofits in Early 2025, Urban Institute
- BBB Standards for Charity Accountability, BBB Wise Giving Alliance
- Cover photo by Alicia Razuri on Unsplash